Gold Gain Points To Market Meltdown
Dow Plunges 282 Points, Ends Near Day's Low
August 10, 2002
THOM CALANDRA'S STOCKWATCH
SAN FRANCISCO (CBS.MW) -- When gold stocks rise sharply as a group on
extremely heavy volume, it's always a sign of trouble ahead for the
overall stock market.
Analysts say the 7.5 percent advance for U.S.-traded gold shares
earlier this week -- the sector's largest increase since May 2000 --
points to renewed interest in the metal. It's also a sign investors
accept the possibility that the stock market, and those few
industries still holding onto gains this year, could come crashing
down in coming days or weeks.
On Wednesday, the stock market was getting pounded - down 2 percent
for major indexes with 90 minutes to go in the trading day. Down
volume on the New York Stock Exchange was overwhelming up volume by
almost a 9-to-1 margin.
Gold's price, subdued until this week, is up almost 20 percent from
12 months ago. The spot price Wednesday in New York was $316.40 an
ounce, holding onto all of its almost $4 gain the previous day.
Trading activity in top gold mining companies like Newmont Mining
(NEM: news, chart, profile), Gold Fields Ltd. (GFI: news, chart,
profile) and Barrick Gold (ABX: news, chart, profile) this month is
regularly exceeding the stocks' three-month volume averages.
Analysts and newsletter writers say the metal and corresponding
shares have been winners at a time when the stock market and the U.S.
dollar are losers. What is new is the growing belief that the metal's
gains, and those of gold mining companies, are telltale signs of an
impending stock-market meltdown.
"What the market seems to be saying is that we've seen the end of
Wall Street's oversold relief rally, and the resumption of gold's
bull trend," said Bob Bishop, the longtime editor of Gold Mining
Stock Report. "I'm guessing that (the July 5) lows in many gold
stocks are likely to be the lows for some time, principally because
of the amount of bad news that appears to be baked in the cake of the
broader market and the U.S. dollar. That's good for gold, and bad for
U.S. stocks and the dollar."
Gold shares with 90 minutes to go Wednesday were down about 1 percent
after the powerful rally earlier in the week, as measured by the XAU
(XAU: news, chart, profile) index of major miners.
Barry Cooper, gold mining analyst at CIBC World Markets in Toronto,
is convinced gold's gains will proceed lockstep with the fall of the
dollar against other major currencies, such as the euro. The euro is
flirting with the $1 level for the first time since January 2000.
The rise of gold mining shares "suggests the broader markets are not
that healthy, but most people could have surmised that," says
Cooper. "The equities have been leaders to bullion for the past while
so I would expect we will see some further strength coming." One of
Cooper's top gold stocks, Canada's Goldcorp. (GG: news, chart,
profile), staged a 9 percent gain in a single day this week.
Joseph Duarte, a Dallas fund manager and author of "Successful Energy
Sector Investing," says the mining companies' stellar stock-market
gains this year bode poorly for other industries. "Gold is the refuge
du jour, because there isn't any place else to run. Hospitals, HMOs,
drugs, banks, oil -- everything that is 'safe' is getting clobbered,"
Duarte said Wednesday.
Homebuilder stocks were one of the few industries holding onto
substantial gains this year. No more. Says Duarte: "Look at the
charts of the home builders, especially Toll Bros. (TOL: news, chart,
profile) and Ryland Group (RYL: news, chart, profile). These stocks
are clearly under heavy selling pressure, suggesting that even these
invincible stocks are being abandoned. That may well be the sign that
indeed capitulation is either here or just around the corner, as when
people are truly getting scared."
Not everyone expects a surge for gold this summer, traditionally a
weak season for jewelry sales. James Turk, founder of payment system
GoldMoney.com and a longtime precious metals newsletter editor, sees
a trading range of $300 to $320 an ounce for gold "in the next two to
three months, then gold makes another attempt to hurdle $325 in
September or October."
Mike Darda, an economist at Polyconomics Inc. in Parsippany, N.J.,
sees a "slight upward bias" for dollar-gold prices, "but not a bias
that will cause the price to rise by leaps and bounds. We'd need an
attack on Iraq for that -- and we still think that prospect remains
remote." Polyconomics sees gold prices moved most by the supply and
demand for currency and bank reserves, which are influenced in turn
by tax policy expectations and geopolitical developments.
"For gold to fall hard, we would need to see a turn in U.S. fiscal
policy (i.e. a cut in the capital-gains tax) or another big downshift
in global political risk," Darda says.
John C. Doody, editor of Gold Stock Analyst, expects gold mining
shares will continue to reflect gains in the metal. The "rule of
thumb is a 1 percent change in gold price yields a 3 percent change
in stock price," says Doody. "This is because the price increase adds
directly to the bottom line, or takes from it if the price falls.
Witness the recent $15-an-ounce slide, or 5 percent, that saw most
stocks off 15 percent to 20 percent."
Higher gold prices provide gold miners with more cash flow from their
annual production. Investors in turn are more willing to pay a higher
price for a miner's reserves, generally 10 times annual production
for the best companies. "The price increase," Doody says, "makes all
the reserves more profitable and may make marginal ounces profitable
now, which weren't economic at a lower price."
Thom Calandra's StockWatch appears each trading day.
© 1997-2002 MarketWatch.com, Inc. All rights reserved.